The Five Best Science Fiction Books - Iain Banks Included
84Five best science fiction books? Why did I pick only five? For the challenge I suspect. For the record – science fiction is my all time favorite writing genre, and limiting myself to only five is the challenge. I will start with what I consider to be the ultimate sci-fi book and, although I am listing five here, I do not really consider them in any sort of order. One is no better than the other. But they are head and shoulders above everything else.
No 1 – Dune, by Frank Herbert
Ignoring the inevitably doomed-to-failure attempts to turn this into a movie, this is without a doubt the ultimate sci-fi book. An entire new political system, and in fact an entire religious order devoted to politics. The Bene Gesserit. An imaginary substance, known as “spice,” which enhances mental abilities, allows travel between worlds at faster than light speed, and which becomes, of course, “the most valuable substance in the universe.”
This spice grows only on one planet – Dune, a desert planet long thought to be largely devoid of life. Hidden within the nooks and crannies of this planet are the Fremen, a warrior like people oppressed for millennia. Throw in a truly bad guy, and a truly good guy sent to lead the Fremen out of servitude and you have a recipe for success. Frank Herbert was a genius and this is his best work by far. A must read sci-fi book. You can, unfortunately ignore all the subsequent books, and especially those written by Herbert's son after his death. Marketing garbage.
No2 – Excession, by Iain Banks
This was hard. I cannot make list of the best 5 science fiction books without at least one Banks’ book. In fact, I almost added all of Iain Banks’ books to the list and left it at that. Banks has “created an entire culture called the “Culture,” from the building blocks of our own and a number of other imaginary cultures. Where will humanity end up? Banks knows and I suspect his writing is somewhat prophetic. Assuming we do not wipe ourselves out completely, I have no trouble imagining this is our future. Once again politics and intrigue form the basis of the story, although – in this one – nothing happens.
But, nothing happens in such a way as to force you to turn the pages to find out what doesn’t happen next. Wonderful reading, although I suggest reading some of the other culture books before this one, and the books after – well, not so good. This was the pinnacle of Iain Banks career as far as I am concerned. I nearly added “Consider Phlebas,” “The player of games,” or “Use of weapons,” but this is the one.
Iain Banks is also a man after my own heart: disgusted by the British government Inc’s involvement in the Iraq war, he disowned his citizenship, cut his passport into tiny pieces and posted it to the Prime Minister’s office. The money-grubbing troglodyte in office at that time completely misunderstood the message and offered him a new one.
No3 – The Stainless Steel Rat, by Harry Harrison
Another tricky one. How can I have a 5 best list without including Harry Harrison? Not possible, but picking just one book from the prolific writings of Mr. Harrison is all but impossible; still, I will go with the stainless steel rat, which spawned a succession of later books and pretty much mirrors my own opinion on the inevitability of government taking over the little man.
The lead character, the “Stainless Steel Rat,” mistakenly thinks he has pulled off a successful bank robbery, only to discover he has been tricked into working for the government. In the Special Corps, the elite law-enforcement and spy agency led by the former greatest crook in the Galaxy, Harold P. Inskipp, he is coerced into the ranks of an organization that is entirely constituted of ex-criminals. Fantastic reading and a wonderful imagination definitely makes my top five.
No 4 - Time Patrol, by Poul Anderson
Another prolific writer, Poul Anderson’s commentary on life, the universe and everything (you know where I am going with number 5) are spot on, as are his imaginary worlds and time travel scenarios. Once again very difficult to pick a single book from the many, but Time Patrol does it for me. Another long series was spawned from the first one, but any serious science fiction reader needs this in their collection.
The Time patrol follows a number of special agents in their travels through time to repair any damage done by evil operators intent on subverting the time line for their personal gain. Pretty sure this spawned the movie “Time cop,” but no credit was given as far as I know. Another must-read author and hard to choose just none for the list.
No 5 The Hitch Hiker’s Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams
The hitchhiker’s guide is one of the funniest and truest books ever written. The earth is demolished to make way for a hyperspace bypass and the local inhabitants were ignorant of the appeals procedure, mainly because they had thus far failed to develop faster than light travel, preventing them from visiting the necessary complaints department on Alpha Centauri.
Reading this book will take you to familiar places instantly recognizable as being no different in hyperspace than in your hometown. Adams was witty, funny and a keen observer of the human condition. He was also a committed atheist and coined some of my favorite phrases including: "Isn't it enough to see that a garden is beautiful without having to believe that there are fairies at the bottom of it too?"
Not as prolific a writer as most of the others on this list, but everything he ever wrote is worth reading. Incidentally, the hitchhikers guide is a five book trilogy, and they are all worth reading.
Now I have finished, I am stricken to remember all the authors that should have had a book on this list. Philip K Dick, Larry Niven, E.E. “Doc” Smith, Isaac Asimov, and numerous others. I will have to make a top ten, or top twenty list now….
CommentsLoading...
I absolutely love the hitchikers guide to the galaxy. The movie did it no justice, and I would anyone who hasn't read it to do so as soon as possible. A classic!
Do you consider the late Michael Chriton a science fiction writer? One of my all time favorites.
Nice work, Mark - Dune is a fantastic book. I am surprised that you have not included your favourite author, Hubbard ;)
Looking forward to the top twenty version!
Tough - too many to pick from. I could probably pick five authors more easily - how do you decide between Asimov's Robot and Foundation series?
Dune, I-Robot, 2001, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? The last is a series, but Stephen Donaldson's 'Gap' Series is fantastic - his fantasy stuff is good, too.
You made me wish I could find time to read more - rarely read a book these days. I used to read science fiction all the time, my faves are John Wyndham & Isaac Asimov.
yOU KNOW, i HATE SCIENCE FICTION AND FANTASY, don't know why, it gives me nightmares and preys on my mind!
Very true, Mark, and Litany has made it even more difficult - Wyndham is a good call. H G Wells' 'War of the Worlds' is another one. Maybe you should try a top 100 :D
Just newly into sci-fi I guess I have a little reading to do. Thanks for the suggestions.
Great list -- I've got some catching up to do, so I'm looking forward to that? Thanks.
As a would be Si-Fi writer myself, I have to say that this genre is wonderful because of the freedom it allows you as a writer. The only limits are that of your imagination. Frank Herbert's Dune is also my all time favorite, but I have to part company with you on the following 4, although they all have merit and belong on anyone's all time list. My list would include L.Ron Hubbard's Battle Field Earth (he's a much better si-fi writer than he is theologian in my opinion) Gordon R.Dickson's Dorsai series, and David Brin's Uplift series. Of Course, anyone's list is purely a matter of taste, and no list should be considered the end all be all. Great hub as ususal,
Nice list. Haven't read Steel Rat yet! Kept by passing, might have to get to it soon.
Well done. I cannot pick a top ten list in anything and admire those who try.
My problem is in the labels, Sci-Fi, Sci-Fi/Fantasy, Sci-Fi/Horror - they are three different categories, at least. (Hitchhikers Guide needs its own category ...) I have read only 4 of the 5 so now I must buy another book, thank you for that ... :)
jfx
I enjoyed reading HG Wells as a youngling. Though one of his books was less than sci-fi. Loved Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy. Introduced to me via my dad - a great reader and appreciator of sci-fi.
Read Dune way back when and was stupid enough to start watching the film. Never finished it. Was bloody garbage.
Mark - I meant I didn't watch the film through. I read the book. The film was truly awful.
I forgot to say in the forum - Have you read Moorcock's "Behold the Man?". I have a sneaking feeling that you may like that one.
Same here - I used to love browsing charity shops and second hand book shops. I also had to give most of my books away when we came over here - I tried to persuade the missus that books are more important than furniture, but the lady was not for turning :(
Not good - I detest Wilbur Smith books. There is a library here, but my Greek is not yet good enough to plough through a novel, so I stick to the newspapers!
Amen Brother! Dune is and always will be an exceptional read. I love all of the Dune books by Frank Herbert. His son's books, not so much, however, I love the series so much, I have read them all as well. But I must say, when I go from the prequels to Dune....its like getting a breath of fresh air, and the real writing begins....
Yeah, Mark, do the list of twenty, or fifty if you feel like it. I like your reviews--short, to the point. I'm not a huge sci-fi fan but I'd put Dune at the top of the list myself. I liked the Tolkien trilogy, too, but I don't even know if that counts as sci-fi, or fantasy, or what.
Number 4. Great choice. I am a fan of Poul Anderson and found the series of stories on that theme to be an engrossing read. Hitchhiker was just plain hilarious. Thumbs up. Thanks for the hub.
Great hub. I am also a fan of Douglas Adams,though not primarily for its science fiction content. My second hub was entitled the "worlds worst poet" because I wanted to find out on whom Adams based the universe's worst poet.....
It turned out to be a school friend of his called Paul Johnstone
My top five are Doomsday by Connie Willis; The Lathe of Heaven by Ursula LeGuin; A Wrinkle in Time by Madeleine L'Engle; The Giver by Lois Lowry and Slaughterhouse Five by Vonnegut.
Ray Bradbury's " Fahrenheit 451 " is the classic sci-fi novel...
Robert Heinlein's " Stranger in a Strange Land " merits a top five notch...
Arthur C Clarke's " 2001: A Space Odyssey " is another classic deserving top five mention...
I agree with your pick at # 4 Poul Anderson's " Time Patrol "....
Vonnegut's " Slaughterhouse Five " should be in there too...
So many great sci-fi writers, so many personal perspectives...Enjoyed this Hub...Thanks, Larry
I'd add Bradbury's "Martian Chronicles." I found it to be an entertaining and touching work of art.
omg wheres stranger in strange land or any of cs lewis i am broken hearted truly lol
no, these are all wonderful and dune is a favourite of mine...I will not fear/fear is the little mind killer...love to you... bb...
now can I put together my own list too?
I agree with maven101 that Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451 is definitely a good read and deserves a place. Slaughterhouse Five I also agree with.
Yes, of course, lots of opinions and one person's 5 won't be another person's 5.
Dune I would definitely put up there as one of maybe the top ten.
Harry Harrison, yes, and The Stainless Steel Rat is a good choice though mind you I would have gone with Make Room! Make Room!
The Hitch Hiker's Guide Guide makes most people's top ten so why not a top 5?
Not bad.
I'm sorry, I just can't agree to a "best science fiction" list that doesn't include Niven and Heinlein! :-)
Asimov, Mark!!! Asimov :) Come on, the Foundation Series? It has to be there.
I agree with Dune completely. I got caught up in it reading the newer additions by his son. Serena Butler is a fascinating character! And of course I had to start reading the original series. Now my husband knows that any Dune book is a good bet when he goes gift buying for me.
I would have picked 5 different books, but these are all great. Good Hub.
Try Walter Miller's 'A Canticle For Leibowitz'. This is possible the all-time great SF book, and great in any genre.
You picked two of my favorites--Dune and Hitchhiker's. The other three I'll have to check out, though I'm sure I'm going to like the Poul Anderson story. He's never let me down.
I have to agree with others that Heinlein and Asimov should be on the top 5, but I feel you on having to choose only 5. So many good choices.
Heinlein's later stuff tended to get a little long-winded, like "Stranger" and "Number of the Beast," but each book started out with a roar. And Niven's "Ring World!" I could go on and on, but then you've limited it to 5.
Thanks for provoking some thought on my favorite genre.
One of these days, I'll get back to writing some of my own. Until then, lots more to read.
Thanks Mr. Knowles, for a good hub.
--Carl Martin
Asimov not in the top 5? for shame ;)
These are really great books..Thanks for that





































RVDaniels Level 3 Commenter 2 years ago
Oh, man. You left out Heinlein, Asimov and Jack Chalker!